• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

From Inwood Out

  • About
  • New York City
  • Finger Lakes
  • Central New York
  • Adirondacks
  • Capital Region
  • Catskills
  • Hudson Valley

Encounter Goats & Ghosts at the Fainting Goat Island Inn in Upstate New York

Michele · May 19, 2023 ·

Guest room furnished with antiques at the Fainting Goat Island Inn in Nichols, NY.

If you’re visiting the Southern Finger Lakes region and want to stay at an inn oozing with charm and history, I highly recommend the Fainting Goat Island Inn in Nichols, NY. The inn is a convenient place to stay if you’re visiting Owego, or if you’re on your way to or from the Finger Lakes wine trails and need a place to stopover for the night. 

Fainting Goat Island Inn is well known to be haunted and has been repeatedly voted one of the best haunted hotels in the U.S.

The inn’s history as a railroad hotel contributes to its reputation as a paranormal hotspot. Built in the late 1800s, many guests stayed here while in traveling the Erie-Lackawanna Railroad. Presumably, some died and their spectral forms were not able to leave the premises. 

Prior to our arrival, the inn’s haunted reputation led me to imagine a foreboding old mansion with shadowy figures flickering behind third floor windows. 

Instead, we arrived to total cuteness.

Six goats in a pen walking toward the camera.

A pen full of friendly goats greeted us. There was also a pot-bellied pig named Porkchop and some very friendly and furry dogs. The Fainting Goat Island Inn is named after its resident goats. Fainting goats are a breed that appears to actually faint when they experience fear.

A goat resting its head on the ledge of its pen.

The inn sits on the banks of the Susquehanna River and the grounds, in addition to the friendly animals roaming around, are full of lush gardens and looks out onto a 17-acre island in the middle of the river. It is a slice of rural paradise. 

A small portion of the Susquehanna River at sunset.

Along with the adorable welcoming committee, owner Marnie Streit and her partner Bill greeted us. We chatted for a while and then Marnie showed us to our room. We settled in for a friendly, relaxed stay, though I did wonder if we’d have any paranormal experiences. 

We stayed there on a very dark Tuesday night in early November, and we were the only guests at the inn. We stayed in the Fainting Room (each of the five guest rooms is named for a breed of goat), but had Marnie told us to make ourselves at home and wander through the other guest rooms if we wanted to.

I was thrilled to be able to check out the décor and antique furnishings in the other rooms. I especially wanted to read the diaries that Marnie leaves in each room so guests can write down any paranormal activity they witness. 

Antique furnishings in a guest room at Fainting Goat Island Inn in Nichols, NY.

In our guest room, ghostly sightings of two women drinking tea have been reported, and a chair meant for a child has moved on its own in the Nubian Room. In the Angora Room, guests have felt someone sitting on the bed with them or pulling off their sheets during the night, and at least one person reported a feeling of being pinned to their bed.

I didn’t see any evidence of paranormal activity in the guest rooms. I also didn’t see eyes looking back at me in a mirror or hear footsteps on a non-existent staircase, both occurrences which other guests have reported.

I’m not a disbeliever in ghosts but if there are people more perceptive to the nonliving in our presence, I’m not one of them. I do, however, love a good ghost tour or haunted house, and I like to scare myself a little bit (as long as I know I’m safe!), so I loved walking from room to room on that dark night as the late autumn wind whistled through the old inn, reading diary entries of spectral sightings.

Our night in the Fainting Room was mostly uneventful. Matt did wake up throughout the night for unknown reasons. Maybe it was the old house settling in, or maybe the ladies decided to hold their tea party while we slept. 

In any case, we didn’t see or hear anything to report but we weren’t disappointed, and I ended up loving Fainting Goat Island Inn for many reasons. 

The guest rooms are spacious and clean and have the feel of staying in an old, well-kept farmhouse, while the hallways outside the rooms are decorated with haunting photos and antique dolls that honestly were scarier than any potential ghost that’s been reported. 

Spooky black and white photo of a child wearing a white nun's costume and holding a small crucifix.

The rest of the inn is decorated in rich colors with vintage furnishings, and there are plenty of places to fan out and relax, both indoors and out. 

Marnie was gone by the time we got up (she is a teacher by day), but she had left us hot breakfast sandwiches outside our door and a short note, wishing us a good day.

Fainting Goat Island Inn

  • Address: 1311 West River Road, Nichols, NY
  • Ph: 607-972-9849
  • Room rates: Start at $115 per night

Like this post? Pin and save for future reference!

Pinterest graphic with four images from inn: a spooky black and white photo of a child, a goat looking at the camera, a guest room, and a small herd of goats walking toward the camera.
Pinterest graphic with an image of a guest room furnished with antiques at the Fainting Goat Island Inn in Nichols, NY.


  • Share
  • Tweet

Filed Under: Finger Lakes

Primary Sidebar

About

I’m a local NYC writer who helps curious travelers explore New York State beyond the usual sights. I do this through sharing stories, itineraries, tips, and advice on how to get the most out of your travels around the Empire State. Read more.

Contact

  • Contact
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

Categories

  • About
  • New York City
  • Finger Lakes
  • Central New York
  • Adirondacks
  • Capital Region
  • Catskills
  • Hudson Valley

Web Stories

See All Web Stories

Recent Posts

  • Exploring Hamilton Heights: A Hidden Gem in Upper Manhattan
  • 14 Towns in the Finger Lakes Everyone Should Visit
  • 17 Ways to Enjoy Lake George in the Fall
  • 9 Ways to Fall in Love with Winter in the Adirondacks
  • 7 Enchanting Winter Carnivals in the Adirondacks in 2025

Footer

Privacy Policy + Terms & Conditions

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Website Disclaimer

Copyright © 2025 · Daily Dish Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

Scroll Up